Quick view 1857-1909 Flying Eagle & Indian Head Cent 59 Coin Set Good to Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $6,630.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859 CN, 1863 CN & 1865 Bronze Indian Head Cent Trio Good MSRP: Was: $133.00 Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859-1909 Indian Head Cent Brilliant Uncirculated MSRP: Was: $89.00 Now: $79.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859-1909 Indian Head Cents Set of 10 Different Good MSRP: Was: $75.00 Now: $59.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1860-1865 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar & 1995 Civil War FDC Collection MSRP: Was: $268.00 Now: $189.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1873 Seated Liberty 1/2 Dime with Legend Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1873 Seated Liberty 1/2 Dime with Legend Good MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Dime with Legend Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $45.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Dime with Legend Good MSRP: Was: Now: $39.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1861-1865 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar Fine MSRP: Was: $199.00 Now: $159.00 Compare
SALE Quick view 1864 Copper 2¢ Piece & 1865 3¢ Nickel Good with Lincoln Presidential Dollars MSRP: Was: $139.00 Now: $119.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865 2 Cent Piece & 3 Cent Nickel Pair Good MSRP: Was: $125.00 Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865 Indian Head Plain & Fancy Cent Pair Good MSRP: Was: $99.00 Now: $79.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865-1889 Three-Cent Nickel & 1867-1883 Shield Nickel Pair Good MSRP: Was: $120.00 Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1873 Seated Liberty Silver Dollar with Motto Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $1,049.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar with Motto Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $155.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar with Motto Good MSRP: Was: Now: $129.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Quarter with Motto Fine MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Quarter with Motto Good MSRP: Was: Now: $69.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1867-1883 Shield Nickel with No Rays Good MSRP: Was: $75.00 Now: $59.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1857 or 1858 Flying Eagle Cent Good Modeled after the big British copper pennies, the Flying Eagle was the first small cent used in American commerce and set the standard for all future U.S. pennies. Only 17 million were minted in 1857, exclusively by the Philadelphia Mint — about one for... MSRP: Was: Now: $65.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1857-1909 Flying Eagle & Indian Head Cent 59 Coin Set Good to Fine Contains all the Flying Eagle and Indian Head Cents, including super-rarities like the 1877 and 1909-S issues. Grades range from circulated Good to Fine quality. It's the hardest-to-assemble small U.S. penny complete set, including 18 genuine scarcities... MSRP: Was: Now: $6,630.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859 CN, 1863 CN & 1865 Bronze Indian Head Cent Trio Good There were a variety of changes to the Indian Head cent early in the series. This trio includes one of each of the first three types. The inaugural coin was copper-nickel and actually called a nickel because at the time, it was the only coin with nickel... MSRP: Was: $133.00 Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1859 Indian Head Cent Good The first copper-nickel Indian Head issue was originally called a nickel because at the time, pennies were the only coins with nickel content used in American commerce. The composition was altered a few years later due to hoarding during the Civil War... MSRP: Was: Now: $49.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859-1909 Indian Head Cent Brilliant Uncirculated Indian Head pennies are among the most popular and widely collected of all U.S. coins. And now these beloved classic issues are all over a century old. Its famous obverse was intended as a quintessentially American personification of Liberty. The Union... MSRP: Was: $89.00 Now: $79.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1859-1909 Indian Head Cent Extra Fine Indian Head pennies are among the most popular and widely collected of all U.S. coins. Designed by James B. Longacre, the famous obverse was intended as a "quintessentially American" personification of Lady Liberty. Common folklore would have it that the... MSRP: Was: Now: $39.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1859-1909 Indian Head Cents Set of 10 Different Good We'll choose ten different affordable dates from this beloved classic series which was minted from 1859-1909. Each vintage cent carries the famous Indian Princess engraving that represents a quintessentially American Liberty personification. The Union... MSRP: Was: $75.00 Now: $59.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860 Indian Head Cent Good The quintessentially American Indian Head cent was struck for commerce beginning in 1859. Because of their new copper-nickel content, the first Indian Head pennies were known as white cents. In 1864, when nickel was needed for armaments during the Civil... MSRP: Was: Now: $35.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1860-1865 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar & 1995 Civil War FDC Collection 1860-1865 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar, Save now on this coveted Civil War era silver half dollar. Featured is Lady Liberty holding a shield in one hand and a liberty cap in the other, as she seems to gaze westward. The eagle on the reverse holds a... MSRP: Was: $268.00 Now: $189.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1873 Seated Liberty 1/2 Dime with Legend Fine The 1860-1873 silver half dime type transferred the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA to the Seated Liberty side; agricultural wreath reverse with wheat, corn, cotton and tobacco. Well preserved Fine condition. Date of our choice.15.5mm MSRP: Was: Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1873 Seated Liberty 1/2 Dime with Legend Good Date of our choice. MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Dime with Legend Fine The 1860-1891 Seated Liberty/Legend dime features an agricultural wreath displaying the North's corn and wheat and South's cotton and tobacco. Our choice of date. 17.9mm MSRP: Was: Now: $45.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1860-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Dime with Legend Good Minted since 1837, the Seated Liberty silver dime underwent a design change in 1860. Although the same Liberty motif was kept on the obverse, stars were removed and the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA was relocated to the reverse. This variety was... MSRP: Was: Now: $39.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1861 Indian Head Cent Good 88% Copper/12% Nickel4.6g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1861-1865 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar Fine The Liberty personification holds the U.S. shield in one hand and a liberty cap with the other, as she seems to gaze westward in the days of an expanding United States. The eagle on the reverse holds a peace branch and arrows of preparedness. Well choose... MSRP: Was: $199.00 Now: $159.00 Compare
Quick view 1862 Indian Head Cent Good 88% Copper/12% Nickel4.6g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $29.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1863 Indian Head Cent Good Struck for 50 years, the Indian Head cent began circulating under the shadow of impending Civil War and continued on through the Reconstruction era, the second industrial age and into the Progressive era. With great buying power in their day, most... MSRP: Was: Now: $35.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1864 Copper 2¢ Piece & 1865 3¢ Nickel Good with Lincoln Presidential Dollars The curious copper 2¢ piece and 3¢ nickel both came to be as a result of the Civil War. As the war raged on and 16th President Lincoln fought to keep the U.S. unified, small change became scarce. After the war, nickel was no longer needed for armaments... MSRP: Was: $139.00 Now: $119.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1864 Indian Head Cent Bronze Good This historic Indian Head bronze cent replaced the copper-nickel type at the height of the Civil War, when nickel was needed for armaments. Its 95% copper content remained the standard for U.S. cents until 1982. Our Good quality retains basic designs and... MSRP: Was: Now: $49.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1864 Indian Head Cent Copper Nickel Good Produced at the height of the Civil War, this historic 1864 cent was the final copper-nickel type issued. Later issues produced that year were 95% copper, as nickel was needed for armaments. Just 13.7 million of these pennies were output during that... MSRP: Was: Now: $85.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1864 Indian Head Cent with L Fine 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MML - is the initial of the designer (Longacre). VERY hard to see in lower grades (G-F). Located at the back of Liberty's neck right of the ribbon. MSRP: Was: Now: $359.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1864-1871 Two Cent Piece Fine This curious two cent piece was introduced during the Civil War, after a severe coin shortage developed. It's a great collector favorite today, partly because it was the first coin to carry the inscription In God We Trust. In its short minting span a... MSRP: Was: Now: $75.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1864-1871 Two Cent Piece Good Yes, there once was a real U.S. 2 cent piece! This short-lived and long-obsolete coin introduced the first inscription of In God We Trust. The motto appeared because of increased religious sentiment during the Civil War. By 1864, the conflict had taken a... MSRP: Was: Now: $49.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865 2 Cent Piece & 3 Cent Nickel Pair Good This original odd couple of American numismatics came about due in part to the coin shortage that developed during the Civil War. The bronze 2¢ coin is a great collector favorite today — noteworthy for the first appearance of the motto, IN GOD WE TRUST... MSRP: Was: $125.00 Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1865 Indian Head Cent Good 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $49.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865 Indian Head Plain & Fancy Cent Pair Good There were a variety of revisions to the Indian Head cent early in the series, including a change of composition due to the Civil War. Cent pieces from 1864 on (including these 1865 issues) were struck in bronze alloy. Two decidedly distinctive varieties... MSRP: Was: $99.00 Now: $79.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1865-1889 Three Cent Nickel Fine U.S. 1865-1889 Liberty 3 Cent Nickel. Obsolete for well over a century, this historic coin was introduced after the Civil War, when super-hard nickel was no longer needed for armaments. Only 32 million ever existed. Even in their own day there weren't... MSRP: Was: Now: $55.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865-1889 Three Cent Nickel Good U.S. 1865-1889 Liberty 3 Cent Nickel. Obsolete for well over a century, this historic coin was introduced after the Civil War, when super-hard nickel was no longer needed for armaments. Only 32 million ever existed. Even in their own day there weren't... MSRP: Was: $45.00 Now: $35.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1865-1889 Three-Cent Nickel & 1867-1883 Shield Nickel Pair Good 1865-1889 Three-Cent Nickel. Obsolete for well over a century, this historic coin was introduced after the Civil War, when super-hard nickel was no longer needed for armaments. Only 32 million ever existed. Most got a lot of use in commerce and the great... MSRP: Was: $120.00 Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866 Indian Head Cent Good 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $159.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1867 Shield Nickel with Rays Fine Minted after the Civil War to replace fractional currency, this was America's first nickel 5 cent piece. The Mint's chief engraver, James B. Longacre, created the obverse design based on his previous 2 cent piece: shown is the familiar U.S. shield... MSRP: Was: Now: $135.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1867 Shield Nickel with Rays Good Date of our choice. MSRP: Was: Now: $69.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1873 Seated Liberty Silver Dollar with Motto Fine First struck in 1840, the Seated Liberty silver dollar later underwent a design modification in 1866 to include a scroll with "IN GOD WE TRUST" on its reverse, thereby creating this second "with motto" subtype. These "with motto" 90% silver dollars were... MSRP: Was: Now: $1,049.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar with Motto Fine The big 90% silver 1866-1891 Seated Liberty half dollar of Christian Gobrecht displays the U.S. shield and liberty cap; the eagle holds a peace branch and the arrows of preparedness. Fine quality. Our choice of date. 30.6mm MSRP: Was: Now: $155.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Half Dollar with Motto Good This elegant Seated Liberty engraving was used on six different U.S. coin denominations in the 19th century. Liberty holds the U.S. shield in one hand and raises the liberty cap aloft with the other as she seems to gaze westward into the days of an... MSRP: Was: Now: $129.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Quarter with Motto Fine The 1866-1891 Seated Liberty/Motto quarter bears IN GOD WE TRUST above the reverse's eagle. Fine quality. Our choice of date.24.3mm MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1866-1891 Seated Liberty Silver Quarter with Motto Good MSRP: Was: Now: $69.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1867 Indian Head Cent Good 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $195.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1867-1883 Shield Nickel No Rays Fine Minted after the Civil War to replace fractional currency, this was America's first nickel five-cent piece. Chief Engraver James B. Longacre created the obverse design based on his previous two-cent piece which featured the familiar U.S. shield and... MSRP: Was: Now: $89.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1867-1883 Shield Nickel with No Rays Good Minted after the Civil War to replace fractional currency, this was America's first nickel 5 cent piece. The Mint's chief engraver, James B. Longacre, created the obverse design based on his previous 2 cent piece: shown is the familiar U.S. shield... MSRP: Was: $75.00 Now: $59.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1868 Indian Head Cent Good 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $165.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1869 Indian Head Cent Good With a mintage of just 6,420,000, the 1869 Indian Head cent is a sought-after issue in the beloved series. That year and for three years beyond, outputs were especially limited making these specimens of special interest to collectors. Because of the... MSRP: Was: Now: $229.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1870 Indian Head Cent Good Collectors love Indian Head pennies! The quintessentially American coin features a native princess who was intended to be a Liberty personification. At the time, virtually every other U.S. coin denomination displayed Liberty, but the Wild West flavor of... MSRP: Was: Now: $215.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1871 Indian Head Cent Good Everyone loves this historic U.S. Mint penny, whose Indian Princess design has a quintessentially American look. Just 3,929,500 of these classic 95% copper cents were minted over fourteen decades ago. With great buying power in their day, most endured... MSRP: Was: Now: $199.00 Add to Cart Compare
Quick view 1873 Indian Head Cent Good 95% Copper/5% Zinc & Tin3.11g19mmNo MM MSRP: Was: Now: $99.00 Add to Cart Compare
SALE Quick view 1873-1885 Trade Dollar Very Fine As one of the most unusual coins in our history, these big silver dollars were struck for use primarily for the purpose of export trade with Asia. Before its creation, the preferred coin was the Mexican silver eight reales, which contained more... MSRP: Was: $699.00 Now: $549.00 Add to Cart Compare